You open your renewal notice expecting the usual bill, but the amount is higher than you remember. Or maybe the price has not changed at all, so you assume there is no reason to look around. In either case, a quick comparison could tell you whether your current policy still fits your needs and budget. Drivers should generally compare car insurance quotes at least once a year. Comparing every six months can also make sense because many auto policies are renewed twice a year. Your renewal date is a natural reminder to review what you have, check what has changed and see what other insurance companies may offer.
You do not have to contact one company after another on your own. Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc. (IIA) can help you compare car insurance rates from more than 20 insurance companies. One of our bilingual agents can explain your options in English or Spanish, answer your questions and help you start a quote.
Get A Personal Auto Insurance Quote
How often to shop for car insurance
An annual car insurance rate comparison is a good baseline. But every six months works well, too, especially if that is when your policy renews. Put a reminder on your calendar a few weeks before the renewal date so you have time to review your options without feeling rushed. Even when your address, vehicle and driving record have stayed the same, the price of insurance may change. Insurance companies can update their rates, available discounts and underwriting rules. The company that offered a competitive price last year may not have the right fit for your budget this year.
If your premium recently increased, compare quotes before the new policy term begins. You can also learn more about why your insurance rates are higher by going to the IIA Knowledge Center. If your rate stayed the same, it may still be worth shopping. Another insurer could offer a lower price for comparable coverage, or your current policy may remain the better value. The only way to know is to compare.
Why car insurance rates change over time
Car insurance pricing is based on several factors. Some relate to you, while others involve your vehicle, location, or changes in the insurance market.
Your personal risk profile can change
Accidents, claims, tickets and other driving violations may raise your premium. Adding a driver can also change the price, particularly if that person is young, newly licensed, or has a different driving record. Removing a driver may affect the rate as well, depending on the insurer's rules and who lives in your household. In states where credit-based insurance scoring is permitted, changes in your credit information may affect your rate. State laws vary, and insurers do not all use or weigh this information in the same way.
Your vehicle can affect your rate
Buying a different car can change what you pay for collision and comprehensive coverage. A newer or more expensive model may cost more to repair or replace. Theft rates, replacement-part prices, and the complexity of repairs may also influence the premium. On the other hand, certain safety or anti-theft features may qualify for a discount. Ask an agent about which vehicle features an insurance company recognizes and how much they could affect the quote.
Your location matters
Moving to another ZIP code, city or state can change your rate. Insurance companies may consider local claim frequency, traffic, theft, weather and repair costs when setting prices. That means a company that offered an affordable rate at your previous address may not be the least expensive choice at your new one. Always give the insurer the correct address where the vehicle is usually kept.
Insurance companies change their pricing
Insurance companies regularly review their rates based on claim trends, inflation, vehicle repair costs, and market conditions. Each company uses its own pricing and underwriting approach, so two insurers can quote very different premiums for the same driver. This is why an auto insurance price comparison can be useful. When you compare car insurance rates across multiple companies, you get a clearer view of the options available for your current situation.
Best times to compare car insurance rates
You do not have to wait for an annual reminder. Certain events are good reasons to shop sooner.
Before your policy renews
Start comparing a few weeks before renewal. Use your current declarations page to match the same coverage limits, deductibles, and endorsements on each quote. This gives you time to ask questions and make a decision before the next term begins.
After your premium increases
A rate increase does not always mean you did something wrong. Insurance company pricing, repair costs and claim trends can affect premiums even when your driving record has not changed.
Before accepting the higher price, see what other companies may offer. Look for comparable coverage, not just the lowest monthly payment.
When you buy or replace a car
Different vehicles can cost very different amounts to insure. If possible, request quotes before you finalize a vehicle purchase. The insurance cost may help you compare the total expense of two models you are considering.
If the vehicle is financed or leased, the lender or leasing company may require comprehensive and collision coverage. People often call a policy with liability, comprehensive and collision “full coverage,” but the term does not refer to one standard coverage and does not cover every possible loss.
When you move
Your price can change after a move, even within the same state or city. Compare quotes when you change ZIP codes and update the address where your car is usually parked. An inaccurate garaging address could lead to a revised premium or underwriting concerns.
When you add or remove a driver
Adding a teen, spouse, or another family member may significantly affect your rate. Removing someone who no longer drives the vehicle may lower the premium in some situations. Household-driver rules vary, so give each company complete information and ask how the change affects your options.
After a ticket, accident or claim
Insurance companies do not price tickets, accidents, and claims in exactly the same way. One company may offer a more affordable option than another for a driver with a recent incident.
If you expect your premium to rise at renewal, compare ahead of time. An early car insurance quotes comparison gives you room to review the details instead of choosing a policy at the last minute.
When your coverage needs change
Paying off your car may give you more flexibility because a lender will no longer set comprehensive and collision requirements. Before dropping either coverage, consider the vehicle's value and whether you could afford to repair or replace it after a covered loss.
Driving fewer miles may make you eligible for a low-mileage discount. But if you start using your vehicle for deliveries, rideshare work or business tasks, you may need different coverage. Tell your agent how you use the vehicle so the policy can be quoted for that use. A car insurance rate comparison is also worth considering whenever your current insurer no longer fits your budget or coverage needs.
Get A Personal Auto Insurance Quote
How to compare car insurance quotes
A useful comparison starts with accurate information. Taking a few minutes to prepare can make the quotes easier to review.
Gather your current policy information
Have these details ready:
- Your current declarations page
- The year, make, model and vehicle identification number, or VIN, for each vehicle
- Driver information for everyone in the household
- Your current coverage limits and deductibles
- Your claims and driving violation history
- Your estimated annual mileage
- Your preferred payment plan
Your declarations page is especially helpful because it summarizes the coverages, limits, deductibles, and vehicles on your current policy.
Compare the same coverage limits
For an apple-to-apple comparison, ask each company to quote the same liability limits and deductibles. Match uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage, comprehensive, collision, rental reimbursement, roadside assistance and state-required coverage when applicable.
A cheaper quote may simply include less coverage, a higher deductible or different optional benefits. Review the details before deciding that one price offers better value.
Get quotes from multiple companies
Compare at least three quotes so you can see how prices and policy options differ. Getting more quotes may give you an even broader view of the market. IIA makes this step easier by comparing options from more than 20 insurance companies. Instead of entering the same information again and again, you can speak with one agent who will help you review available choices.
Ask about discounts
Discount availability and eligibility vary by company and state. Ask whether you may qualify for:
- A multi-policy discount
- A multi-car discount
- A good-driver discount
- A defensive-driving discount
- A low-mileage discount
- A paperless-billing or automatic-payment discount
- A paid-in-full discount
- A student discount
Review these common auto insurance discounts, then ask an IIA agent which ones may be available with the companies quoting your policy. A careful auto insurance price comparison should consider the final premium after eligible discounts, along with coverage and payment terms.
Should you switch car insurance companies after comparing quotes?
Comparing does not mean you have to switch. Sometimes the review confirms that your current policy still works for you. In other situations, changing companies may make sense.
When switching makes sense
You may want to consider switching if:
- You can get the same or broader coverage for a lower price
- Your current insurer raised your rate
- Your coverage needs changed
- Another company offers customer service, claims support or payment options that better fit your preferences
- You qualify for discounts with another insurer
Look at the full policy offer, including coverage limits, deductibles, fees, payment schedule and service options. Price matters, but it is only one part of the decision.
How to switch without a coverage gap
Set the new policy to start before you cancel the old one. Confirm the effective date and time and notify your lender or leasing company if needed. Cancel the old policy only after the new policy is active, then request written confirmation of the cancellation.
IIA agents can help coordinate the switch and review effective dates with you. That support can help you avoid an unintended lapse in coverage.
How often should high-risk drivers compare car insurance quotes?
Drivers who have tickets, accidents, limited U.S. driving history or other complex insurance needs may benefit from comparing quotes more often, such as at each renewal. Prices can vary widely because insurance companies evaluate these situations differently.
Drivers with tickets, accidents or SR-22 requirements
Not every insurance company treats a violation or accident the same way. Some insurers focus on drivers with records that other companies may consider high risk. If you need an SR-22 filing, compare companies that offer the filing in your state and ask about the total policy cost.
Drivers with little or no U.S. driving history
Newly licensed drivers, drivers with a foreign license and people without prior U.S. insurance may receive a wide range of prices. Comparing multiple companies can help identify insurers that consider nonstandard driver profiles.
An IIA agent can discuss your driving and insurance history in English or Spanish. The agent can also tell you what documents may be needed to complete a quote.
Drivers who recently improved their record
Compare again when a ticket or accident becomes older, when a lapse is no longer part of the period an insurer reviews, or after you have maintained continuous coverage. The exact time an incident affects pricing varies by company and state, so ask an agent when another review could be worthwhile.
Common mistakes to avoid during a car insurance rate comparison
Shopping for a policy is about finding the right balance of price, coverage and service. Avoid these common mistakes as you review quotes.
Comparing only the monthly payment
A low monthly payment can come with a larger down payment, installment fees, a longer payment schedule or lower coverage limits. Compare the total premium, the amount due today and the cost of each installment.
Choosing state minimum coverage without understanding the risk
State minimum liability coverage may cost less, but it may not be enough to pay all covered costs after a serious accident. If damages exceed your policy limit, you could be responsible for the remaining amount.
The cheapest option is not always the best value. Ask an agent to explain different limits and how each choice changes the price.
Forgetting to include all drivers
Insurance companies need accurate information about household members and people who drive the vehicle. Leaving out a driver can change the quote later or create underwriting issues. Tell the agent who lives with you and who regularly uses each car.
Letting coverage lapse
A lapse may lead to higher rates in the future and could create legal or registration consequences, depending on your state. Keep your current policy active until the replacement policy has started.
Staying with a policy that no longer fits your budget
Loyalty can feel convenient, but your needs and the insurance market can change. If your current premium no longer works for your budget, compare options before reducing important coverage or missing a payment.
FAQs about comparing car insurance quotes
How often should I compare car insurance quotes?
Compare at least once a year. Some drivers may benefit from comparing every six months, particularly when their policy renews.
Is it bad to compare car insurance quotes often?
No. Comparing quotes does not usually hurt your credit, and it can help you understand whether your current rate is competitive.
Does comparing car insurance rates affect my credit score?
Where allowed, an insurance company may use credit-based insurance scoring when preparing a quote. This is typically not the same as a hard credit inquiry used for a loan and generally does not affect your credit score. Practices and state laws vary, so ask the agent how your information will be used.
How many car insurance quotes should I compare?
Compare at least three quotes. Reviewing more can give you a broader view of available prices, coverage options and payment plans.
Can I switch car insurance before my policy ends?
Yes, in most cases. Start the new policy before canceling the old one so you do not create a lapse. Also ask whether your current insurer charges a cancellation fee and whether you may receive a refund for any unused premium.
Shop car insurance quotes with IIA
A regular car insurance rate comparison may help you avoid paying more than necessary. Just remember to compare the same limits and deductibles, then review the policy's coverage, payment terms and service along with the price.
You do not have to sort through all those details alone. IIA works with more than 20 insurance companies, and our bilingual agents are ready to answer your questions in English or Spanish. We can listen to what you need, compare available options and help you choose a policy that fits your situation and budget.
Ready to start the conversation? Call IIA at 1-855-478-3705 to speak with a Spanish bilingual agent or get a quote online today.